Standard Paper-Bag Cookery — Edition Insights
Edition facts
For Standard Paper-Bag Cookery — Edition Insights, the stored edition analysis reports 39,680 words, 2 hr 53 min estimated reading time, and 7 detected text sections.
The text analysis averages about 18.3 words per sentence, while the detected sections provide another way to judge how the source is divided.
Project Gutenberg metadata also associates the work with “Paper bag cooking,” connecting these edition facts with the source record’s subject description.
Calculated from edition completeness, EPUB availability, text structure and catalogue metadata. Not a user rating.
How this score is calculated
- Description quality20 pts
- Title & short description10 pts
- Source metadata20 pts
- Text length15 pts
- Chapters / structure15 pts
- EPUB file integrity20 pts
Total of 100 points, scaled to a 2.5-5.0 range. Editions with an empty description or a missing EPUB file are not scored.
Read the Text
WHAT IS PAPER BAG COOKERY?
THE principles contained in Paper-bag Cookery are not new. Woodsmen and hunters have known for ages that if they wanted fish or game done to a turn, a jacket of clay outside the meat which was protected from soil by leaves or corn husks, gave, on removing the clay case, the very quintessence of delicate, savory cookery.
Now within the last two years, a series of experiments has resulted in the perfecting of a system of Paper-bag Cookery that revolutionizes the old time kitchen drudgery with its unending round of greasy pots and pans to be taken into account.
The advantages of this method of cooking are manifold. They may be epitomized thus:
I. It makes food more savory and nutritious.
II. It is sanitary. No dust can reach the article being cooked and, the cooking accomplished, the bag can be thrown into the stove or kitchen scrap basket with no temptation for a lazy maid to tuck away a greasy pan in the dish closet for the delectation of "germs" or roaches.
III. It is economical. Not only does it save the time and strength of the housewife with no aftermath of dirty cooking dishes to be washed, but it prevents the shrinkage of meats as caused by ordinary cookery. Nothing is lost, because there is no evaporation; careful experiments prove that the weight of the cooked food tallies almost exactly with the weight of the raw. There is also a great saving of fuel, some claiming as high as 40 per cent., owing to the less time required in Paper-bag Cookery. While this may be a generous estimate it is certain that Paper-bag Cookery takes on the average, one-third less time than other cooking.
IV. With ordinary care there is no danger of food burning, and no deterioration in flavor if left in the bag some little time before serving.
V. It is odorless; a great thing, this, for the flat-dweller who has to cook in restricted quarters, taking care always that cooking odors do not permeate the house.
VI. Its price is not prohibitive. Indeed, it is most reasonable.
Paper-bag Cookery calls for no big outlay of money, no patent stove oven, no complex apparatus or appliances. All that is necessary is an oven of any sort--coal, gas, electric, wood or oil--a broiler, a paper bag specially and sanitarily prepared,--grease proof and waterproof,--a wood cookery dish if the food contains liquid or a number of separate ingredients, and something to cook therein. Another convenience are the wire clips for fastening the mouth and corners of the bag, which can be purchased wherever the bags are sold.
THE KIND OF PAPER BAG TO USE.
While a sheet of heavy foolscap paper made into a bag serves for the cooking of a single chop--it is self-evident that for larger proportions, larger bags and bags from strong, absolutely sanitary paper must be used. While there are bags and bags now upon the market, not all fulfill these essential conditions. After much experimenting, the Continental Paper Bag Co., of Rumford, Maine, and New York City, has succeeded in producing the ideal bag which may now be found in varying sizes, at all the large house-furnishing stores, grocers, butchers, etc., or the bags may be ordered direct from headquarters. These bags are put up in bulk in bundle lots, or in sealed packages of assorted sizes. Each of the sealed packages contains thirty bags of assorted sizes with the necessary clips and a small book of recipes with full directions. Retail price 25 cents a package--fifty packages to a shipping bundle.
In order to make paper bag cookery of the greatest value to housewives, both as regards cleanliness and ease of operation, to say nothing of the many cases where the flavor of the food is actually improved, the author heartily recommends the use of specially prepared wood cookery dishes. These dishes are most inexpensive, varying in price from about thirty for ten cents to six for ten cents, depending upon size. They can be purchased wherever the paper bags are sold,--department stores, house furnishing stores, grocery stores, etc., etc., or may be obtained direct from the Oval Wood Dish Company, Delta, Ohio. The food is placed in the wood cookery dish and the dish is put into the bag. The advantage lies in the fact that should the bag break, the food and juices are saved in the dish and the oven will not be soiled by leakage. Then again, the food can be removed from the bag when finished with greater ease than when the dish is not used. The dishes are so cheap that they can be thrown away with the bag after the food is prepared.
GENERAL DIRECTIONS FOR USING THE BAG.
Emma Paddock Telford's Standard Paper-Bag Cookery (1912) presents itself as a guide to a specific cooking method, yet the excerpts reveal a curious tension between the book's stated purpose and its actual content. The catalog subject "Paper bag cooking" suggests a focus on that technique, but the provided text devotes far more space to conventional sauce recipes—such as Hollandaise, Curry, and Spanish sauces—than to instructions for cooking in paper bags. The foreword emphasizes "practicability" and aims to minimize labor for the housewife, but the sauce section reads like a standard early-20th-century cookbook, with detailed proportions and techniques that do not involve paper bags at all.
A Method in Name Only?
The excerpts include a lengthy section on sauces—Hollandaise, Horseradish, Mint, and others—that are prepared in saucepans, not paper bags. This raises questions about how central the paper-bag method truly is to the book. The foreword explicitly states that soups, omelettes, and macaroni are better done by other methods, suggesting a selective application of the technique. Yet the sauce recipes, which occupy a substantial portion of the excerpts, make no mention of paper bags. The reader might wonder: are these sauces meant to accompany paper-bag-cooked dishes, or does the book simply repurpose conventional recipes under a trendy title? The catalog subject may overstate the book's novelty.
Precision and Practicality in Recipe Writing
Telford's recipe style is notably precise, with specific measurements and step-by-step instructions. For example, the Hollandaise sauce calls for butter "washed" in cold water to remove salt, then divided into three parts and added sequentially. The Curry sauce specifies a "scant tablespoonful" of curry powder and warns not to let the flour-butter mixture brown. This attention to detail aligns with the foreword's promise of "clear and concise" directions. However, the excerpts also include recipes like "French Mustard Sauce, Creole Style" that blend multiple culinary traditions (mustard, sugar, egg, vinegar, olive oil), reflecting the eclectic tastes of the era. The practical tone is consistent, but the content often strays from the paper-bag premise.
The Audience and Its Assumptions
The foreword addresses "the woman who does her own work" and the "epicurean but frugal housewife," indicating a target audience of middle-class homemakers seeking efficiency. Yet the sauce recipes assume access to ingredients like curry powder, olive oil, and fresh herbs—not universally available in 1912. The book also includes a "Time Table" and chapters on "Paper Bag Menus" and "Easiest Dishes for Beginners," suggesting a structured approach. However, the excerpts do not show these sections, leaving the reader to infer how the paper-bag method integrates with the broader recipe collection. The catalog subject may accurately reflect the book's intent, but the evidence suggests a more conventional cookbook with a specialized gimmick.
Readers approaching Standard Paper-Bag Cookery should be prepared for a cookbook that often sets aside its titular method in favor of standard sauce and dish preparations. The excerpts hint at a work that is more about general early-20th-century cooking than a revolutionary technique. To fully assess the book's claim, one would need to examine the chapters on actual paper-bag cooking—such as those on fish, poultry, and vegetables—which are not included here. The sauce section, while detailed and practical, may not satisfy those seeking a focused guide to paper-bag cookery.
There’s something tender about old cookbooks like Emma Telford’s, where efficiency feels almost hopeful. I found myself thinking how her paper-bag tricks—meant to free a housewife’s hours—echo the quiet thoroughness of Mrs. Beeton's Dictionary of Every-Day Cookery The "All About It" Books — Reading Notes. Both speak to a slower time when even the smallest kitchen secret was a small, private victory.
There are no reviews for this eBook.
How will you remember this book?
Save your reaction, strongest insight, and memorable passage.